The Beauty Of Flight
UN raping children, as usual

Contractors and Embeds Under UCMJ?

Hhhhmmm.   This is kind of a mess.  Noah Shachtman of DefenseTech.org reports for Military.com that five little words made it into some legislation that may have an interesting effect on contractors and embeds.

The key graphs are below:

Since the start of the Iraq war, tens of thousands of heavily-armed military contractors have been roaming the country -- without any law, or any court to control them. That may be about to change, Brookings Institution Senior Fellow P.W. Singer notes in a Defense Tech exclusive. Five words, slipped into a Pentagon budget bill, could make all the difference. With them, "contractors 'get out of jail free' cards may have been torn to shreds," he writes.  They're now subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the same set of laws that governs soldiers.  But here's the catch: embedded reporters are now under those regulations, too.
<...>
Given that journalists are not armed, not contracted (so not paid directly or indirectly from public monies) and most important, not there to serve the mission objectives, this would probably be too extensive an interpretation. It would also likely mean less embeds. But given the current lack of satisfaction with the embed program in the media, any effect here may be a tempest in a tea pot. As of Fall 2006, there were only nine embedded reporters in all of Iraq. Of the nine, four were from military media (three from Stars and Stripes, one from Armed Forces Network), two not even with US units (one Polish radio reporter with Polish troops, one Italian reporter with Italian troops), and one was an American writing a book. Moreover, we should remember that embeds already make a rights tradeoff when they agree to the military's reporting rules. That is, they have already given up some of their 1st Amendment protections (something at the heart of their professional ethic) in exchange for access, so agreeing to potentially fall under UCMJ when deployed may not be a deal breaker...

Read the whole interesting piece here.

Update:  P.W. Singer wrote the article for Defense Tech which is edited by Noah Shachtman.

Comments