Posted By Blackfive • [December 11, 2012]
Holy s#!t, this is not good...sent by a soldier high up in a major combat HQ...you are going to be very angry about this:
The US Army has drafted a new handbook on how to interact with our Afghan counterparts while in country. The
proposed Army handbook suggests that Western ignorance of Afghan
culture, not Taliban infiltration, has helped drive the recent spike in
deadly attacks by Afghan soldiers against the coalition forces.
Many of the
confrontations occur because of [coalition] ignorance of, or lack of
empathy for, Muslim and/or Afghan cultural norms, resulting in a violent
reaction from the [Afghan security force] member," according to the
draft handbook prepared by Army researchers.
But it has drawn
criticism from U.S. Marine Gen. John Allen, the top military commander
in Afghanistan, who aides said hasn't—and wouldn't—endorse the manual as
written. Gen. Allen also rejected a proposed foreword that Army
officials drafted in his name.
Unfortunately, the WSJ version is paid only, but here's a taste of the article:
...The draft handbook uses Maj.
Bordin's conclusions to psychologically prepare troops for serving in
Afghanistan. A summary includes views of some U.S. soldiers that Afghan
forces engage in thievery, are "gutless in combat," are "basically
stupid," "profoundly dishonest," and engage in "treasonous collusion and
alliances with enemy forces."
The draft handbook offers a list of
"taboo conversation topics" that soldiers should avoid, including
"making derogatory comments about the Taliban," "advocating women's
rights," "any criticism of pedophilia," "directing any criticism towards
Afghans," "mentioning homosexuality and homosexual conduct" or
"anything related to Islam."
"Bottom line: Troops may experience
social-cultural shock and/or discomfort when interacting with" Afghan
security forces, the handbook states. "Better situational
awareness/understanding of Afghan culture will help better prepare
[troops] to more effectively partner and to avoid cultural conflict that
can lead toward green-on-blue violence."
Cultural sensitivity is one thing. But. How any American soldier can avoid criticism (especially witnessing that behavior) of how they treat women and children is beyond me. This is almost a parallel to how we began fighting communisim in central America in the 70s/80s. Look the other way. Don't get involved. Don't fight, just advise (and if they don't listen, no big deal). It was when we were allowed to make moral and ethical decisions/actions that we succeeded there. It was when we stopped the avoidance nonsense that changes began to happen.
When we led by example.
We. Are. Americans. Dammit.
Our men and women, one of the most diverse groups of people in the world, fight for the idea that ALL people are born free. PERIOD.
Update: Bookworm Room says "It’s not smart for the Army to call its own troops stupid — but nobody seems smart in Obama’s America"