« Gen. Petraeus & Uncle J- Eye to Eye on Dead Tangos | Main | The unavoidable BS at The New Republic »

The New Republic's Correspondent a Fake?

Posted By Blackfive • [July 18, 2007]

A mission from the Weekly Standard - or more accurately, this is a "Bust Their Chops" opportunity to debunk some letters that are just too much "exactly what the left wing wants to hear" for me to take at face value. If you can help, email the Weekly Standard. Or, if you'd feel more comfortable contacting me, I'm at blackfive - AT - gmail - DOT- com.

Fact or Fiction?

A mission for milbloggers:

The New Republic runs a piece in this week's issue titled "Shock Troops" (sub. req.) and authored by Scott Thomas--described by the magazine as a "pseudonym for a soldier currently serving in Baghdad." "Thomas" is the author of two previous dispatches from Iraq for the New Republic, both of which recount deeply disturbing anecdotes (in one, an Iraqi boy who calls himself James Bond has his tongue cut out for talking to Americans; in the other, dogs feast on a corpse in the street). His latest piece is even more disturbing. It recounts several instances of gross misconduct by the men in his unit, some of which are, to echo the title of his piece, deeply shocking--If they are true--a big if, according to several people with experience in Iraq. One described it to me as sounding like a "pastiche of the 'This is no bullshit . . . stories soldiers like to tell."

The first episode puts "Thomas"'s unit at a "chow hall" at an unnamed base. A woman eating there is wearing "an unrecognizable tan uniform, so I couldn’t really tell whether she was a soldier or a civilian contractor." The woman's face is described as having been "more or less melted, along with all the hair on that side of her head," by an IED. She sits down for lunch next to the men. Here's how "Thomas" describes what happens next:

We were already halfway through our meals when she arrived. After a minute or two of eating in silence, one of my friends stabbed his spoon violently into his pile of mashed potatoes and left it there.
“Man, I can’t eat like this,” he said.
“Like what?” I said. “Chow hall food getting to you?”
“No—with that fucking freak behind us!” he exclaimed, loud enough for not only her to hear us, but everyone at the surrounding tables. I looked over at the woman, and she was intently staring into each forkful of food before it entered her half-melted mouth.
“Are you kidding? I think she’s fucking hot!” I blurted out.
“What?” said my friend, half-smiling.
“Yeah man,” I continued. “I love chicks that have been intimate—with IEDs. It really turns me on—melted skin, missing limbs, plastic noses . . . .”
“You’re crazy, man!” my friend said, doubling over with laughter. I took it as my cue to continue.
“In fact, I was thinking of getting some girls together and doing a photo shoot. Maybe for a calendar? ‘IED Babes.’ We could have them pose in thongs and bikinis on top of the hoods of their blown-up vehicles.”
My friend was practically falling out of his chair laughing. The disfigured woman slammed her cup down and ran out of the chow hall, her half-finished tray of food nearly falling to the ground.

Is it possible that American soldiers would be so sadistic when confronted by a badly burned woman, who may be a fellow soldier? Well, yes: Anything is possible when it comes to human depravity. But consider: these are enlisted men who, by the author's own account, don't know who this woman is or what rank she might hold. (Incidentally, wouldn't soldiers be able to distinguish a soldier from a contractor--especially if she is a regular at the chow hall?) Would they really ridicule her with raised voices in a public place, on "one especially crowded day"?...

There's a lot more - both quotes and questions - at the Weekly Standard.

Update July 18:  A trusted source says that the FOB in question, FOB Falcon, was turned over to the IA/IP a year or two ago.  (Incorrect info.  There is a IA battalion but the rest of the FOB is USA.  Updated from a source on Falcon, see below.)

Another states that the driver in the article would have been beaten by his own troops for putting them in danger of IEDs.

Another from an Infantry Sergeant: 

I just read this story, Major, and it's bullshit, sir. Nobody that would have been melted by and IED would be alive. No way. I've SEEN IED victums, remember, [redacted] was killed by an IED, face blown off and feet gone. [redacted] did not live. If need be I can provide more than one witness to the event. I know of two Soldiers that were burned to death by propane IEDs , [redacted] and [redacted], both died a horrible death. This story is bullshit at the least and the worst fiction at the best.

Update 0h-Dark-30 July 19: An Army Officer on Falcon emails this note:

Sir,
I am and have been an avid reader of your milblog for many years and wanted to answer your request for help with the entry about the TNR article 'Shock Troopers'.

I am one of the many thousand American soldiers at FOB Falcon.  We do have an IA Battalion here, but they are on a completely isolated portion of the camp.  I don't mean to contradict your trusted source about the ownership of this place, but I'm sitting in my barracks right now typing this email here on the FOB.  Without naming units or giving specific personnel counts, I can assure you this is definitely an American post.

In the 11 months I've been here I've never once seen a female contractor with a burned face.  In a compact place like this with only one mess hall I or one of my guys would certainly have noticed someone like that.  There are a few female contractors, I think maybe a dozen, but none fit the horrific description given in that article.  Further, I've personally seen guys threatened with severe physical harm for making jokes of any kind about IED victims given the number of casualties all the units on this FOB have sustained.  It is not a subject we take lightly.  Gallows humor jokes do get told, but extremely seldom and never about anyone they actually know or are in the presence of.

Given the friends in the S-2 shop of my battalion and how often I talk to them about what's going on in our AO and AI I can also tell you no reports whatsoever have been sent up - or down from MNCI - about a mass grave of any kind.  We find bodies all the time, sure, but graves?  None.

The part about running over the dog, in my opinion, is somewhat plausible, but I doubt the PL or CO of that individual would let them do it more than once if they valued the lives of their men at all.  The vehicles we drive are all top heavy and violent swerving to hit a dog is not advisable.

As for the human skull bit, I know that any NCO worth his salt, and most certainly a PSG or higher, would literally crush a Joe for taking his ACH helmet off in the middle of a mission only to put a portion of human skull on his head.

You've probably received multiple emails about all this already, but I just wanted to help crush the bullshit surrounding this story.  Thank you for your milblog and for all you do for us overseas.


 PermalinkComments (29)TrackBack (19) Subscribe to BlackFive   

Comments

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfadb53ef00e00995b3b28833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The New Republic's Correspondent a Fake?:

» Scott Thomas: Fact or Fiction? from Op For
Some of you may be familiar with Scott Thomas and his New Republic dispatches. Thomas, who writes under a pseudonym, claims to be an American soldier serving near FOB Falcon near Baghdad. His writing -there have been a total of... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 19, 2007 1:16:31 AM

» Lies & More Damn Lies from ROFASix
Why would someone fabricate stories to denigrate our men and women in Iraq except in an attempt to demonize them as some want to do with the entire war? If you subscribe to the New Republic ... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 19, 2007 10:29:01 AM

» H&I Fires July 19, 2007 from Argghhh! The Home Of Two Of Jonah's Military Guys..
Open post for those with something to share, updated through the day. New, complete posts come in below this one. Note: If trackbacking, please acknowledge this post in your post. That's only polite. You're advertising here, we should get an... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 19, 2007 11:22:34 AM

» Fact or fiction? An update from Blog-o-Fascists
Power Line Last night we noted the New Republic's "Shock troops" article by the pseudonymous "Scott Thomas" po... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 19, 2007 11:30:05 AM

» Gruesome Stories from Anonymous Sources from baldilocks
And certainly we've seen these before, both confirmed and debunked. From The New Republic (subscription required):I saw her nearly every time I went to dinner in the chow hall at my base in Iraq. She wore an unrecognizable tan uniform, [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 19, 2007 12:09:48 PM

» Battle Buddies from MilBlogs
I for one would like to know whether "Scott Thomas" and his buddies are the sick little pieces of shit described in The New Republic or simply figments of some other sick little piece of shit's imagination. UPDATE: Black Five... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 20, 2007 6:44:04 AM

» http://instapundit.com/archives2/007344.php from Instapundit.com (v.2)
THE TROOPS USED TO BE HEROES. Then the media made them victims. Now it's making them evil, like the hordes of "Jenjis Khan." This will make betraying them more palatable. We've seen this pattern before. UPDATE: Reader Wright Steenrod emails:... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 20, 2007 7:52:37 AM

» The Return of Winter Soldier from Villainous Company
I would like to talk, representing all those veterans, and say that several months ago in Detroit, we had an investigation at which over 150 honorably discharged and many very highly decorated veterans testified to war crimes committed in Southeast... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 20, 2007 8:03:51 AM

» Some absolute BS from 'The New Republic." from discarded lies - hyperlinkopotamus
Some absolute BS from 'The New Republic." [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 20, 2007 1:02:19 PM

» The New Republic's from Public Secrets: from the files of the Irishspy
The current issue of The New Republic contains an article called "Shock Troops," which purports to detail barbaric behavior by American troops in Iraq. The author, writing under a pseudonym, claims to have been one of those soldiers. The article [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 20, 2007 1:06:18 PM

» Bloggers Raise Red Flags Over New Republic's 'Baghdad Diarist' from SWJ Blog
22 July Washington Post - Bloggers Raise Red Flags Over New Republic's 'Baghdad Diarist' by Howard Kurtz. [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 22, 2007 5:54:14 AM

» http://www.keshertalk.com/archives/2007/07/tnrandmilblogs.php from Kesher Talk
Like almost everyone associated with the military who has read it, professional journalist Thomas Lipscomb thinksthe TNR "Scott Thomas" story stinks to high heaven. But in a letter to the Washington Post’s media columnist, Howard Kurtz, Lipscomb wonder... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 22, 2007 11:27:45 AM

» The "Scott Thomas" Lies from Flopping Aces
I'm real late to this party but wanted to chime in a bit. I'm talking about the Scott Thomas reporting done from Iraq....or that is what we are supposed to believe anyways. As I'm sure you know it all started... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 22, 2007 6:42:17 PM

» Will the Blogosphere Defend Our Military the Same from Blue Star Chronicles
I ask this question in all sincerity. I believe the blogosphere was the driving force behind the defeat of the bill that would have given amnesty for illegal aliens. It could do the same for our Fighting Forces. Our Vietnam Veterans came home to c... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 22, 2007 8:51:56 PM

» Doubting Thomas: Simple Questions for the New Republic from Confederate Yankee
As time wears on, it seems increasingly unlikely that the writings of the pseudonym-shielded soldier "Scott Thomas" in the New Republic are anything other than works of macabre creative fiction. "Thomas" has written three "dispatches" for the New Repub... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 23, 2007 12:51:00 AM

» More Disinformation from The New Republic from The Shield of Achilles
The first claim probably sounded credible to the civilians at TNR, but it is impossible. Anyone badly injured is evacuated out of the country. They aren't just left hanging around, especially on a FOB. A burn victim, particularly burns of the face an... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 23, 2007 11:04:26 AM

» BattleBuddies from Mudville Gazette
What needs to be said about Scott Thomas? How far into The New Republic's fabricated war story did I have to get to recognize it was a fabricated story? Answer: Not very far. Here's the first line:I saw her nearly every time I went to dinner in the cho... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 26, 2007 8:36:35 AM

» Defamation of the Troops or Troops Run Amok? from Vista On Current Events
A couple of weeks ago The New Republic ran a sensational article entitled "Shock Troops" by an author using the pseudonym of Scott Thomas. Although I found the story doubtful, ... [Read More]

Tracked on Jul 26, 2007 11:23:34 PM

» Jihadis and Their Bloggers from Snooper
Jihadi Trolls and Bloggers And The New Republic either fell for it or know all about it and don't care. And this is no.. Please see the plethora of posts... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 4, 2007 3:00:24 AM