« Happy May Day, Commies! | Main | Godspeed Sergeant Funcheon »

The END of Military Blogging

Posted By Blackfive • [May 02, 2007]

The most excellent Noah Shachtman of Wired's Danger Room has a great article with lots of milblogger reaction to the new OPSEC regulations that will end military blogging as we know it.  Yes, that's right - the end of soldier blogging from the war zones.

Army Squeezes Soldier Blogs, Maybe to Death
Noah Shachtman Email 05.02.07 | 2:00 AM

The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has learned. The directive, issued April 19, is the sharpest restriction on troops' online activities since the start of the Iraq war. And it could mean the end of military blogs, observers say.

Military officials have been wrestling for years with how to handle troops who publish blogs. Officers have weighed the need for wartime discretion against the opportunities for the public to personally connect with some of the most effective advocates for the operations in Afghanistan and Iraq -- the troops themselves. The secret-keepers have generally won the argument, and the once-permissive atmosphere has slowly grown more tightly regulated. Soldier-bloggers have dropped offline as a result...

Read the whole piece.

Next, be sure to read Major Elizabeth Robbins award winning paper about military blogs "Muddy Boots" - which General Petraeus praised.  It is pure genius and I'm glad Noah linked to it.  I believe that Major Robbins is or is on the way to somewhere dangerous.

The Bottom-Line to the this bad piece of regulation:  The soldiers who will attempt to fly under the radar and post negative items about the military, mission, and commanders will continue to do so under the new regs.  The soldiers who've been playing ball the last few years, the vast, VAST, majority will be reduced.  In my mind, this reg will accomplish the exact opposite of its intent.  The good guys are restricted and the bad continue on...

Operational Security is of paramount importance.  But we are losing the Information War on all fronts.  Fanatic-like adherence to OPSEC will do us little good if we lose the few honest voices that tell the truth about The Long War.

Instead, the US Army should adopt Major Robbins recommendations, allow for unit bloggers, and restrict bloggers with the same rules as the military gives embed reporters (with UCMJ exceptions).  Maybe, then, we can start winning some battles on the information front.

Update:  Steve Schippert sends this link to a video by Brad Levinson of the first panel of the 2006 MilBlog Conference.  At the very end, I make a prediction that I've been praying would never happen.

"If the Army restricts bloggers, all you will have are pissed-off dissident bloggers who are willing to take a risk...every Article-15  schlep will be blogging and all of the guys in this room who are trying to get the stories out, will not.  That'll be the end."

Update 2:  Wired also has an interview posted with the creator of the new regulation.  And treating reporters as Al Qaeda moles.

Update 3:  Reader Paul asks if I'll continue to post messages and emails from my friends in the war zone.  For my answer, see below.

Update 4:  John, a US Army Reserve Officer in Iraq, writes:

If the mil thinks they can keep this reservist from blogs, KMFA

Update 5:  General Casey is not the most Public Affairs minded General ever.  Can't say much else on a PG13 blog.

Update 6:  Just did an interview with Wavelength (Tech Radio) about this issue.  The link is to the raw interview (mp3 file).  The edited version will hopefully include Noah Shachtman and will be on Public Radio across the country.

Update 7 05-03-07: Army releases announcement (I'll post when there's an official link) which essentially is stepping back from the stricter language of the regulation.  This is a smart and welcome change, although it will not change, nor republish, the regulation.

Here is my response from the comments:

The Army is stepping back on this. This wasn't an overblown reaction to the reg. The reg was poorly written. The Wired article accurately reflected the changes in the regulation. And now, General Officers are on the move to prevent it from doing damage. The Army is doing the right thing here. This announcement is a welcome change...however, the "announcement" does not reside within the reg, and therefore, commanders, when consulting the regulations, won't know about it unless it's disseminated widely (like, say, at a milblog conference).

<...>

Outside of Special Ops, I highly doubt that many commanders would ever take a liberal interpretation of any regulation, let alone a regulation pertaining to OPERATIONAL SECURITY?!

Taking a different tact than what the reg dictates is a substantial opportunity for demotion or a stay with all expenses paid at ol' Ft. Leavenworth.


 PermalinkComments (136)TrackBack (35) Subscribe to BlackFive   

Comments

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341bfadb53ef00d835335b0469e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The END of Military Blogging:

» Army crack down on bloggers from Michelle Malkin
Stupid! Stupid! Stupid! Via Noah Shachtman: The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has learned. The directive, issued April... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 9:55:28 AM

» Army crack down on bloggers from Robert B. Steely, MSgt, USAF
Stupid! Stupid! Stupid! Via Noah Shachtman: (Posted from MichelleMalkin.com) The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 12:21:45 PM

» The End of MILBLOGS from MilBlogs
I posted a round-up of reports about the new OPSEC Regulation over at Dadmanly, links, excerpts and commentary. But here's the Executive Summary version. Here are the must reads for today: Shachtman’s Report in Wired Companion Interview with Regulation... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 12:28:02 PM

» http://instapundit.com/archives2/004762.php from Instapundit.com (v.2)
BULLET, MEET FOOT: The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has learned. The directive, issued April 19, is the sharpest... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 2:08:26 PM

» Losing the War from Technicalities
Everyone is blogging about this, so let me just say, it makes me so angry I want to scream. It appears that General Casey is bound and determined that absolutely no good news about our Army is able to make... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 2:10:44 PM

» The END of Military Blogging? from Bill's Bites
As the saying goes, there's a right way, a wrong way, and a wrong way. [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 2:19:40 PM

» Army weak from THE TEXAS SCRIBBLER
The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer. --Wired NewsA few of the active-duty Iraq and Afghanistan milblogs in my blogroll h... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 2:22:48 PM

» Army To Milbloggers: About Face from Captain's Quarters
The US Army has promulgated a new set of rules for operational security that puts restrictions on the ability of soldiers to write about their experiences in combat theaters. In fact, the change will be so restrictive as to have... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 3:11:14 PM

» The End of Milblogging? from You Served
BlackFive has a piece up on the possible end of soldier blogging from war zones. [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 3:28:50 PM

» How to Lose the Information War for Good: The Death of Combat Blogging from Mary Katharine Ham
The death of combat blogging happened this month. During a war in which soldiers and the administration itself constantly complains that alternative stories and good news are not getting past the exploding-terrorist-of-the-day narrative of the... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 3:34:56 PM

» http://instapundit.com/archives2/004762.php from Instapundit.com (v.2)
BULLET, MEET FOOT: The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has learned. The directive, issued April 19, is the sharpest... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 3:40:21 PM

» The Army's Big Blunder from Hugh Hewitt
The Pentagon has issued new regulations effectively shutting down all active duty military blogs. I find this decision to be so amazingly ill-informed about how the milblogs have served the war effort and the cause of the military as to raise... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 4:04:38 PM

» The Army's Big Blunder from Hugh Hewitt
The Pentagon has issued new regulations effectively shutting down all active duty military blogs. I find this decision to be so amazingly ill-informed about how the milblogs have served the war effort and the cause of the military as to raise... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 5:13:16 PM

» MilBloggers: stop or face UCMJ from Cop The Truth
Sometimes I can't figure the U.S. Army out. With all of the negative crap coming out of Iraq and Afghanistan via the MSM, the Army, in its infinite wisdom, has decided to put a stop to military bloggers. Revised Army [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 5:26:29 PM

» Silencing Mil Bloggers from Flight Pundit
No more Mil Blogging from the front lines? The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has learned. The directive, issued April... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 5:44:02 PM

» Army may be crushing active duty milblogs from Right Thoughts...not right wing, just right.
This is not good. Its not surprising, since were talking about the Army and the powersthatbe in the Army react to changing social circumstances like snails react to salt retreat inward and hope it goes away. Still, it;s n... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 6:33:50 PM

» The Army's Big Blunder from Hugh Hewitt
The Pentagon has issued new regulations effectively shutting down all active duty military blogs. I find this decision to be so amazingly ill-informed about how the milblogs have served the war effort and the cause of the military as to raise... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 7:20:55 PM

» Blackfive.net from Hugh Hewitt
Just finished two segments with Blackfive's Matt about the milblog ban. If anyone in the Army brass is reading this, call him and ask him to come to the Pentagon and figure this out. You can --and should-- read the transcript here a bit later. ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 7:48:45 PM

» Blackfive.net from Hugh Hewitt
Just finished two segments with Blackfive's Matt about the milblog ban. If anyone in the Army brass is reading this, call him and ask him to come to the Pentagon and figure this out. You can --and should-- read the transcript here a bit later. ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 8:00:35 PM

» Blackfive.net And The Milblog Shut-Down from Hugh Hewitt
Just finished two segments with Blackfive's Matt about the milblog ban. If anyone in the Army brass is reading this, call him and ask him to come to the Pentagon and figure this out. You can --and should-- read the transcript here a bit later. ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 8:02:47 PM

» Did sKerry & Hairy tell Casey to shut down Milblog from DoD Daily News
OPSEC ordered Milblogs to be scrutinized by their superiors before being posted for content on April 19, 2007. What happened around 4/19? There are three separate events that took place. [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 8:27:18 PM

» FUBAR from Haft of the Spear
My civilian-ized thoughts on the mil-blogging controversy posted at the SPOT Report at the Examiner.com. Excellent round up and summary thoughts from the usual suspects like Blackfive , OpFor, etc. Where would we be without mil-blogging? Forget the mil... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 9:08:45 PM

» Stupidity Beyond Words from Fuzzilicious Thinking
That's what I think of the new military Internet/Blogging regulations. Get this, though: as a DoD employee, I believe that I (technically speaking) fall under these regulations. And that, more than anything, should tell you how absurdly broad and ... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 9:18:56 PM

» The End of Active Duty Army MilBlogs? from Techography
Blackfive has the scoop Short version is as follows via Wired.com The U.S. Army has ordered soldiers to stop posting to blogs or sending personal e-mail messages, without first clearing the content with a superior officer, Wired News has lear... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 9:34:56 PM

» Laying paving stones of 'good intentions'... from The Steeljaw Scribe
One supposes it was only a matter of time. Thing is, the end result will be the vast majority of good, sound forward deployed milbloggers will fall silent and a veritable greek chorus of malcontents will continue to blog away, undoing all the good pr... [Read More]

Tracked on May 2, 2007 9:46:54 PM

» Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Losing the Information War... from SWJ Blog
... but were afraid to ask. Council discussion here. Wired article [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 4:29:18 AM

» Blue Radar from Radio Left
The Blue State As I post each morning, here are some of the political stories that might not be worthy of their own posts, but are nonetheless newsworthy: The Senate Judiciary Committee is [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 5:15:12 AM

» One Marine Wife Speaks Her Mind About The OPSEC Order Censoring Blogs From Iraq from seejanemom
This Marine Officer's wife choses not to blog about the War in Iraq or GWOT or any other issue directly pertaining to it because she finds it a demoralizing conflict of interest, she is not currently on the front line [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 9:29:24 AM

» The End of Milblogs?! from Flopping Aces
Is this really necessary?! This is the final nail in the coffin for combat blogging, said retired paratrooper Matthew Burden, editor of The Blog of War anthology. No more military bloggers writing about their experiences in the combat... [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 11:38:05 AM

» Military bloggers made to retreat from HiWired Blog
One of the interesting things about modern technology has been the ability of troops in the field to not only e-mail family and friends (so you can get daily updates on their well being) but the efforts of Milbloggers to... [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 12:30:26 PM

» Muzzling the Military from Iraq War Today
...The one big similarity to Vietnam and Iraq has been the loss of ground in the Information War. And now the Army is not only conceding defeat - they're regulating it... [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 12:43:33 PM

» Army: Soldier blogging unchanged in new OPSEC regulation from Homeland Stupidity
Noah Shachtman reported Wednesday at Wired News that new Army regulations would severely restrict soldiers ability to maintain web logs and send personal email, requiring them to clear every single post with a commanding officer. The Army says t... [Read More]

Tracked on May 3, 2007 3:29:47 PM

» Milblog conference in Arlington. Opinion on Army blog restrictions for OPSEC from Military
Mary Catherine ham reports from the Milblogs (of which I'm a member) conference in Arlington VA. I guess the big controversy is the OPSEC rules for military blogs. The new Army regulations, as do most Army regulations, on blogging exist mainly to pr... [Read More]

Tracked on May 5, 2007 1:21:51 PM

» The End of MILBLOGS? from MilBlogs
I posted a round-up of reports about the new OPSEC Regulation over at Dadmanly, links, excerpts and commentary. But here's the Executive Summary version. Here are the must reads for today: Shachtman’s Report in Wired Companion Interview with Regulation... [Read More]

Tracked on Aug 22, 2007 6:21:14 PM

» Military bloggers made to retreat from HiWired Blog
One of the interesting things about modern technology has been the ability of troops in the field to not only e-mail family and friends (so you can get daily updates on their well being) but the efforts of Milbloggers to... [Read More]

Tracked on Sep 11, 2007 9:22:13 AM